Pros & Cons of Amalgam Fillings

According to the ADA, the small amount of mercury in amalgam fillings bonds with other metals in the filling and renders it stable, and thus safe for filling teeth. Amalgams have not been banned in the US or elsewhere, and many dentists continue to use them regularly for restoring back teeth. So why are composite resin, porcelain, and ionomer (glass or resin) fillings replacing amalgams?

Some dentists do not place amalgams, and many patients prefer tooth-colored composite, porcelain, or ionomer fillings to the silver of amalgams. An obvious reason is aesthetics. Made of metals, an amalgam stands out against naturally white teeth. When a person smiles, laughs, or speaks, amalgam fillings may show. Tooth-colored fillings matched to a pateint’s natural tooth shade make the fillings blend seamlessly in a white, bright smile.

Composite fillings are bonded with adhesive to your tooth structure, protecting against decay and strengthening the tooth. This bond can make a composite filling last for seven to ten years, the same life expectancy of an amalgam filling. By contrast, dental amalgams do not form such a bond: they simply form a mechanical barrier to decay. Thus, over time, the amalgam-treated tooth can weaken, often creating a liability to your long-term dental health.

Composite fillings provide long-term bacterial invasion protection, too. Once bonded, a composite filling won’t wear down or change shape, despite the incredible forces of biting and chewing. Bacteria and food particles cannot enter the tooth. However, silver amalgams on biting surfaces can change shape with biting and chewing impact. Tiny cracks in the material or between the filling and natural tooth structure can allow bacterial reinvasion, creating a bigger decay problem than you had at first.

Conservative dentistry is a philosophy in which dentists preserve as much natural tooth structure as possible. Amalgam fillings require more reduction to the tooth – more removal of natural tooth structure – than composite resins. This means that if you want to maximize the amount of natural tooth structure in your mouth, amalgams may not be the right choice.

Moving Forward
Dental amalgams have been used in fillings for 100 years, but times change, and as dental medicine evolves, patients have more choices. These days, fillings made with metals, composites, porcelain, resin, or glass are common. As with all medical and dental procedures, you, as the patient, should stay informed about what’s available so that you can determine the best option for your unique case. If you have amalgam fillings but think composites are a better choice, your dentist can replace the amalgams. For more information, visit the ADA online at

If you’re interested in experiencing patient-centered dentistry, it’s time you scheduled an appointment with Dr. Bob Perkins. We specialize in enhancing Southern California smiles with exceptional cosmetic dentistry and teeth-straightening options from our convenient Malibu and San Francisco area locations. Contact our Malibu dental office at (310) 456-5700. We look forward to making you smile!

Screenshot of magazine Screenshot of magazine

Top Doctor 2020 New Beauty

Malibu Orthodontics | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | ©2010 Bob S. Perkins, DDS
24955 Pacific Coast Highway, Suite C100, Malibu, CA 90265 USA
Dr. Bob Perkins Malibu CA dentist (310) 456-5700
3090 Cochran, Suite E, Simi Valley, CA 93065 USA
Dr. Bob Perkins Simi Valley CA dentist (805) 955-0181